Should I Do the Optional Essay for College Application? And Why Not Consider the Color of the Sky While Deciding?

When it comes to college applications, one of the most common dilemmas students face is whether or not to complete the optional essay. This decision can feel overwhelming, especially when you’re already juggling multiple deadlines, standardized tests, and extracurricular activities. However, the optional essay can be a powerful tool in your application arsenal, offering you a unique opportunity to stand out from the crowd. In this article, we’ll explore various perspectives on whether you should tackle the optional essay, and why it might be worth your time—even if the color of the sky seems irrelevant to the decision.

1. The Optional Essay as a Chance to Showcase Your Personality

• Why It Matters: The optional essay is often seen as a space where you can let your personality shine. Unlike the main essay, which typically has a more formal tone, the optional essay allows you to be more creative and personal. This is your chance to tell the admissions committee something about yourself that isn’t already reflected in your grades, test scores, or extracurricular activities.
• Example: If you have a unique hobby, like collecting vintage postcards or writing poetry, the optional essay is the perfect place to discuss it. This can help the admissions committee see you as a well-rounded individual with diverse interests.

2. Demonstrating Interest in the School

• Why It Matters: Many colleges use the optional essay as a way to gauge how interested you are in their institution. By taking the time to write an additional essay, you’re showing that you’re serious about attending their school. This can be particularly important for schools that consider “demonstrated interest” in their admissions decisions.
• Example: If you’re applying to a school known for its strong engineering program, you could use the optional essay to discuss a specific project or professor that excites you. This shows that you’ve done your research and are genuinely interested in what the school has to offer.

3. Addressing Potential Weaknesses in Your Application

• Why It Matters: The optional essay can also be a place to address any potential weaknesses in your application. For example, if you had a dip in your grades during a particular semester, you could use the optional essay to explain the circumstances and what you learned from the experience.
• Example: If you struggled with a particular subject but worked hard to improve, the optional essay is a great place to highlight your perseverance and growth. This can turn a potential negative into a positive.

4. Standing Out in a Competitive Pool

• Why It Matters: In a sea of applicants with similar grades and test scores, the optional essay can be the difference between blending in and standing out. It’s an opportunity to make a memorable impression on the admissions committee.
• Example: If you have a unique perspective or life experience, the optional essay is the place to share it. Whether it’s growing up in a multicultural household or overcoming a significant challenge, these stories can make your application more memorable.

5. The Risk of Overloading the Admissions Committee

• Why It Matters: While the optional essay can be beneficial, there’s also a risk of overwhelming the admissions committee with too much information. If your essay doesn’t add significant value to your application, it might be better to skip it.
• Example: If you’re already submitting a strong main essay and a detailed resume, adding an optional essay that doesn’t provide new insights could dilute the impact of your application.

6. Time Management Considerations

• Why It Matters: Writing an optional essay takes time, and if you’re already stretched thin, it might not be worth the effort. It’s important to weigh the potential benefits against the time and energy required.
• Example: If you’re applying to multiple schools, each with its own set of optional essays, you might find yourself spread too thin. In this case, it might be better to focus on quality over quantity.

7. The Role of the Optional Essay in Holistic Admissions

• Why It Matters: Many colleges use a holistic admissions process, which means they consider the whole person, not just their academic achievements. The optional essay can be a key component of this process, providing context and depth to your application.
• Example: If you come from a non-traditional background or have faced significant challenges, the optional essay can help the admissions committee understand your journey and how it has shaped you.

8. The Impact of the Optional Essay on Scholarship Opportunities

• Why It Matters: Some scholarships require additional essays, and the optional essay can serve as a practice run for these applications. Additionally, a strong optional essay could make you a more attractive candidate for certain scholarships.
• Example: If you’re applying for a scholarship that values leadership, you could use the optional essay to discuss a time when you took initiative and made a positive impact in your community.

9. The Psychological Aspect of Completing the Optional Essay

• Why It Matters: There’s a psychological benefit to completing the optional essay. It can give you a sense of accomplishment and confidence, knowing that you’ve done everything possible to strengthen your application.
• Example: Even if the optional essay doesn’t drastically change your chances of admission, the act of writing it can help you feel more prepared and in control of the application process.

10. The Final Decision: To Write or Not to Write?

• Why It Matters: Ultimately, the decision to write the optional essay depends on your individual circumstances. If you have something meaningful to share that isn’t already covered in your application, it’s probably worth the effort. However, if you’re unsure or feel that the essay wouldn’t add significant value, it might be better to focus on other aspects of your application.
• Example: If you’re on the fence, consider seeking feedback from a trusted teacher, counselor, or mentor. They can help you determine whether the optional essay is a good use of your time.

Related Q&A

Q: Should I write the optional essay if I’m applying to multiple schools? A: It depends on the schools and your capacity. If the optional essay is unique to each school and you have the time, it can be beneficial. However, if you’re stretched thin, prioritize quality over quantity.

Q: Can the optional essay hurt my application? A: It’s unlikely to hurt your application unless it’s poorly written or doesn’t add value. Make sure your essay is well-crafted and relevant to avoid any negative impact.

Q: How long should the optional essay be? A: Follow the guidelines provided by the school. Typically, optional essays are shorter than the main essay, often around 250-500 words.

Q: What if I don’t have anything unique to say in the optional essay? A: If you don’t have a compelling reason to write the optional essay, it’s okay to skip it. Focus on strengthening other parts of your application instead.

Q: Can I reuse content from my main essay in the optional essay? A: It’s best to avoid repeating content. The optional essay should provide new insights or information that isn’t covered elsewhere in your application.

In conclusion, the decision to write the optional essay for your college application is a personal one that depends on your unique circumstances. While it can be a valuable opportunity to showcase your personality, demonstrate interest, and address potential weaknesses, it’s important to weigh the benefits against the time and effort required. Ultimately, the optional essay is just one piece of the puzzle, and a well-rounded application will consider all aspects of your academic and personal journey.